Journal #10 Is Internet Access a Basic Human Right?

Maxlow, J., & Bernasconi, N. (2010). Is Internet access a basic human right?. Learning and Leading with Technology, 37(6), Retrieved from http://www.iste.org/Content/NavigationMenu/Publications/LL/LLIssues/Volume3720092010/MarchAprilNo6/Point_Counterpoint_Is_Internet_Access_a_.htm

When I think of basic human rights, the right to access the internet sure is not one of them. This article presents two arguments, one presenting the view that the internet is a basic right and the other opposing this view. The individual that believes the internet is a basic right points out that the internet plays a key role in our "freedom of expression, democratic participation, and economic livelihood." She points out that in order to know whats going on in the world and to participate in a number on things the internet is essential. I can't agrue with her when she asks "try to imagine a college graduate in 2020 finding a decent job where Internet skills aren’t important", I cannot image this either, the internet is growing so fast I can't even image what 2020 holds. On the other hand, another individual argues that access to the internet is not a right. He argues that it can enhance intelligence, potential, lifestyle and all of the above, but it is not a right. He argues that, "basic human rights do not govern what an individual can receive". He suggests that the internet is a privilege, not a right. He feels that the internet can aid exercising human rights, but the internet itself is not a right.

Where do you stand on this issue?
I believe that access to the internet is not a basic human right. I think that it is a privilege and not a right. There is no doubt in my mind that the internet is a wonderful tool and enhances plenty aspects in life; although, it is not a "human right" to get to experience this. If the internet was a basic human right then would that mean there would be computers in all jail cells?

Could you incorporate this article in your classroom in some way?
I think it would be a great idea to have students (5th grade and older) read this article. You could prompt students to write a paper presenting their belief. This would first of all make them realize how lucky they are to have such great access to the internet and it would get them to think. This assignment would also introduce them to writing argumentative essays. This article is very interesting and I think our youth would take a great interest in it as well.